Posted in

how to convert vickers hardness to brinell

If you’ve ever struggled with comparing hardness test results from different methods, you’re not alone. I’m Maria, a technical specialist with years working directly with Vickers Hardness Testers for a precision instrumentation company, and one question I get almost every week from our customers—from aerospace machinists to tool and die makers to small metal fabrication shops—is: How do I convert Vickers hardness to Brinell? It sounds simple on the surface, but there’s a lot more to it than plugging numbers into a formula, especially when you’re working with materials where test method accuracy can make or break a part. Vickers Hardness Testers

First, let’s set the basics straight to avoid confusion. Vickers and Brinell are both indentation hardness tests, meaning they measure a material’s resistance to permanent deformation by pressing a hardened indenter into the surface, then calculating hardness from the size of the indent left behind. The key difference is the indenter shape, which drives nearly all conversion rules. Vickers uses a square-based diamond pyramid, with opposite faces at a 136-degree angle, while Brinell uses a large, spherical ball (usually tungsten carbide, or sometimes steel for softer metals) with a standard diameter, most commonly 10 mm.

At first glance, the idea of a conversion seems logical: if one test gives you a Vickers Hardness Number (VHN, or sometimes HV) and another gives Brinell Hardness Number (BHN, or HBW to specify tungsten carbide balls), shouldn’t they line up? But here’s where people run into trouble—those numbers only align perfectly for homogeneous, ductile materials, and even then, only within a specific range of hardness values. Brinell testing has a big drawback with hard materials: when you press a ball into a high-hardness material, the ball itself can deform, skewing the indent size and leading to inaccurate BHN readings. That’s where Vickers shines, especially for hard metals like tool steels, heat-treated alloys, and ceramics, which is why our team works with so many customers who switch between tests but need to compare results.

So, what’s the actual conversion process? First, you need to know the hardness range of your material. For values below approximately 500 HV, the relationship between Vickers and Brinell is close enough that you can use a straightforward empirical formula. The formula most widely accepted by standards bodies like ASTM International and ISO is: HBW = 0.95 × HV. That’s it, for lower hardness ranges. But once HV climbs above 500, that simple multiplier starts to fall apart. For higher hardness, the gap between the two methods widens, and a more precise conversion is needed, based on decades of tested data from material science studies.

Wait, let me be clear: this is not a 1:1 conversion. The reason the 0.95 works for softer materials is because of how the indentations form. For ductile metals, the plastic deformation around the indent is similar enough between the two test methods that their hardness readings track closely. But for hard metals, the indentation geometry changes—Vickers’ sharp diamond creates a different stress distribution than Brinell’s round ball, so the proportional relationship breaks down. If you use the 0.95 multiplier for a 600 HV tool steel, you’ll get a BHN of 570, but actual standardized test data for that material will put it around 550 BHN, a difference that might seem small until you’re inspecting a critical aerospace component where a 20-point hardness gap means the part could fail under load.

That’s why relying on generalized conversion charts is risky. I’ve seen customers at our shop test a hardened steel part with a Vickers tester, get 620 HV, look up a generic chart that says 590 BHN, and order replacement parts that turned out too soft. The issue? The generic chart didn’t account for the test load used for Vickers. Wait—another common mistake: Vickers hardness is calculated using the test load (in kilograms-force) and the indent diagonal, so HV is load-dependent. Brinell is also load-dependent, per standard test protocols, but many people forget that both tests require following the correct load-indent size ratio for their material. For Brinell, the standard rule is to use a load-to-ball diameter ratio of 30D for hard metals, 10D for medium, and 5D for soft metals. For Vickers, you need to choose a load that produces an indent diagonal between 20 and 40 micrometers to avoid surface effects and indentation size effect (ISE), which is a thing both tests suffer from if load is too small.

So, step by step, how to do this correctly for your specific application:

First, confirm your test method validity for your material. If you’re working with a hard metal (HV > 500), Brinell is not a reliable test for your purposes, so converting to Brinell to match old data can lead to errors. If you must compare to historical Brinell results, that’s when a standardized conversion table from a trusted source is essential, not a quick formula. I can’t stress this enough: generic online converters are made for general steel, not for alloys like titanium, nickel-based superalloys, or aluminum, which have unique hardness relationships.

Second, make sure your original Vickers reading is accurate. That’s where our Vickers Hardness Testers come in. A lot of budget testers on the market have inconsistent load accuracy, which throws off HV readings, making any conversion useless. For example, if your HV is off by 20 points because of a flawed tester, your converted BHN will be off by even more. So first, calibrate your Vickers tester regularly against reference blocks per ASTM E384 standards. We provide calibration services for all the testers we sell, because even the best instrument needs consistent upkeep for accurate results.

Third, use the correct conversion resource. For most common steels, the ISO 18265 standard outlines approved conversion values between HV and HBW (the updated Brinell designation that specifies tungsten carbide balls, not old steel balls that deform). For non-ferrous metals like copper or brass, the relationship is different: for soft non-ferrous, the multiplier is closer to 0.98, almost 1:1, because their deformation behavior is more uniform. For example, a 100 HV copper sample will be around 98 HBW, compared to 95 HBW for a steel sample of the same 100 HV. That’s another mistake people make—using the steel multiplier for non-ferrous materials, leading to incorrect results.

Let me share a real customer story to illustrate why this matters. A few months back, we worked with a small custom gear manufacturer who was switching from Brinell to Vickers testing after they had a batch of gears fail. They’d been using an old bench-top Brinell tester with a 5 mm steel ball (not a tungsten carbide one, which is required for hardness above 300 BHN) so their readings were consistently off by 10–15 BHN. They converted their old Brinell data to HV using the generic 1.0 multiplier, which gave them HV values 15 points higher than actual. When they switched to our precision Vickers tester, their HV readings were correct, and when they converted properly using ISO 18265 for medium-carbon steel, they realized their old Brinell test was overestimating hardness by almost 20 points. The gears were actually too soft, not meeting the specification they thought they were, which led to their failure. That’s the kind of costly mistake that comes from skipping proper conversion and using uncalibrated test equipment.

Another point to clarify: conversion is not a replacement for direct testing. The best practice for comparing hardness results between methods is to test the same sample with both Vickers and Brinell, following their respective standards, to create a material-specific conversion for your exact alloy and test conditions. This eliminates the variability from standardized conversion tables, which are averaged across multiple materials. If you’re working with a rare alloy, this is the only way to get accurate comparisons. For example, a nickel-based superalloy used in jet engines has a hardness relationship that doesn’t match carbon steel, so a generic conversion will be far less accurate than a direct test comparison.

Now, let’s talk about common pitfalls that trip up even experienced technicians. First, indentation size effect (ISE). Both Vickers and Brinell can show ISE when very low test loads are used, leading to higher hardness readings than the material actually has. If your HV reading is taken at a load of 1 kgf, that’s a tiny indent, and ISE can make it 5–10 HV higher than a test at 10 kgf. Converting that inflated HV will give you a BHN that’s also too high, leading you to reject parts that meet specifications. For this reason, we always advise our customers to use load options for Vickers testers that produce an indent diagonal of at least 20 micrometers, per ASTM E384 guidelines.

Second, surface preparation. Brinell testing is less sensitive to surface finish than Vickers, because the ball indent spreads out over a larger area. If you’re converting a Vickers reading taken on a rough, unpolished surface, the indent will be distorted, and your conversion will be wrong. Make sure your sample is polished to a mirror finish for Vickers testing, and properly prepared for Brinell (free of scale, burrs, and surface deformations that can skew indent size).

Third, mixing test methods for the same part. If you’re testing a part with a large cross-section, Brinell is great because the 10 mm ball can capture bulk material hardness, avoiding the effects of surface hardening or decarburization. Vickers is ideal for small parts, thin sections, or surface hardness testing (like carburized layers), because the small diamond indent won’t affect the surrounding material. So if you’re converting a surface Vickers reading to Brinell, you can’t use bulk conversion tables—you need a conversion specific to surface hardness, which is outlined in ASTM E140, the standard for hardness conversion of steels.

So, to wrap up the practical steps again, clearly:

  1. Identify your material type (ferrous, non-ferrous, alloy, hardness range)
  2. Confirm your Vickers test is valid: calibrated tester, correct load, proper surface preparation, indent size meets standards
  3. Choose the right conversion resource: ISO 18265 for ferrous metals, ASTM E140 for steels, material-specific data for rare alloys
  4. Avoid simple formulas for hardness above 500 HV—use standardized tables or direct dual testing for critical applications
  5. Remember that Brinell (HBW) is not the same as old HB readings using steel balls, so make sure your data matches the modern Brinell specification

Now, if you’re in the market for a Vickers Hardness Tester, or you’re having trouble with consistent hardness conversions and accurate test results, our team is here to help. We work with everything from small shops upgrading from manual testers to aerospace firms requiring lab-grade automated systems, and we provide full technical support, calibration resources, and guidance on test method selection to make sure your readings are as accurate as possible. Don’t let incorrect conversions or unreliable test equipment lead to costly part failures or rejected batches. Reach out to our team today to discuss your specific hardness testing needs, whether you’re converting historical Brinell data to Vickers, switching test methods, or looking to upgrade your equipment for more precision.

Metallographic Pre-Grinding Machines References
ASTM International. 2020. Standard Test Method for Knoop and Vickers Hardness of Materials (E384). ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA.
ASTM International. 2021. Standard Hardness Conversion Tables for Metals (E140). ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA.
International Organization for Standardization. 2019. Hardness Conversion Tables for Metals Between Vickers Hardness (HV), Brinell Hardness (HBW), and Rockwell Hardness (HRC, HRB) (ISO 18265). International Organization for Standardization, Geneva.
Tabor, D. 1951. The Hardness of Metals. Oxford University Press, Oxford.


Laizhou Metallographic Testing Equipment Co., Ltd.
As one of the leading manufacturers and suppliers of vickers hardness testers in China, we have world-leading production equipment and strong manufacturing capabilities. Please rest assured to wholesale customized equipment at competitive price from our factory. Welcome to contact us for quotation.
Address: TENG GE PO ZI VILLAGE, HU TOU YA TOWN, LAIZHOU CITY, YANTAI SHANDONG, CHINA
E-mail: nicolecheng@lzmetaltest.com
WebSite: https://www.metalnesscn.com/